Crime/Police
Allegations of Evidence Tampering within RVIPF Spark Concerns
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b382a/b382a5222ccf8183844ee7b9e184bad8e15d286e" alt=""
Concerned Citizen Advocates for Police Commissioner’s Removal, Urging Independent Investigation
British Virgin Islands Governor John Rankin has received a letter from a concerned citizen for the removal of Police Commissioner Mark Collins to facilitate an impartial and independent investigation into serious allegations, including the tampering of evidence, against the Royal Virgin Islands Police Force (RVIPF).
The November 2 letter, penned by the concerned citizen stated that “concerns were initially raised in 2023 when allegations were made of an email from the office of the Commissioner of Police of the Royal Virgin Islands Police Force (RVIPF) which was sent to St. Clair Amory, O’Neal Bakker and Cc: to Jacquelyn Vanterpool circulating within the Virgin Islands and the international world. As it relates to a discussion surrounding the arrest and charge of a police officer the matter was discussed by the Commissioner of Police with the DPP and stated that: “The matter has been discontinued by the DPP”. The Commissioner gave certain instructions and various decisions were made by the Commissioner of Police for the evidence to be destroyed and should the video footage be released in the public domain there will be a PSD investigation.”
The leaked email not only raised questions about the internal workings of the RVIPF but also created a public relations crisis. Commissioner Collins when questioned about the email during a recent press conference did not deny its authenticity.
This raised further concerns about the credibility of the RVIPF and its leadership. The concerned citizen points to several other key issues, including the discrepancies in the treatment of officers and joint criminal conspiracy.
“Allegations are made against subordinate Police officers for committing disciplinary or criminal offences and they are being interdicted and removed from office by the Commissioner of Police, during which period of interdiction an investigation is being conducted, and if there is sufficient evidence to substantiate the allegation, then criminal charges will be brought against the officers.”
The correspondence added: “Similarly, the same principle applied to those officers should apply to the Commissioner of Police and those other gazetted officers whose names were mentioned in the email and the office of the DPP, in accordance with equality before the law; they should be afforded the same opportunity to face justice under the criminal justice system.”
The letter stressed that the Commissioner of Police does not possess any legal authority to eliminate evidence in criminal proceedings, as there is no statutory law granting such power.
“There is no statutory law authorising the Commissioner of Police to destroy any evidence in criminal proceedings. The Commissioner has no statutory authority to give instructions to any subordinate Police officers as to the destruction of evidence in any criminal or disciplinary proceedings. Therefore, evidence can only be destroyed by an order made by a court of law.”
“For those very same reasons stated I am of the opinion and have been supported by the statutory law that the Commissioner of Police should be interdicted or removed from office to have a fair and transparent investigation into this matter.”
“I am quite confident that this is not what you want from members of His Majesty’s Royal Virgin Police Force. So I am calling on you to conduct an investigation into the allegations independent of the Commissioner Mr Mark Collin, Deputy Commissioner Mr. St. Clair Amory and Ms. Jacquelyn Vanterpool.”
Collins attended the press conference on Thursday, October 12, 2023, initiated by Governor John J. Rankin, CMG, and Premier and Minister of Finance Dr the Hon Natalio D. Wheatley (R7). During the conference, Collins asserted that the situation was deemed “an internal matter” by the authorities, emphasizing that he had “nothing to hide.” He clarified that the issue revolved around a conflict between two officers and a leaked email he was aware of.
“I will be very clear; it was not evidence related to a particular case. It was between two individual officers, one who threatened to release something about another officer, and I told him not to do it and if he did do it there would be an investigation.”
Crime/Police
Tensions Flare as Parents Confront Elmore Stoutt High School Staff Over Contraband Crackdown
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5d4a6/5d4a6c28593491d8f7c01e52bfa7dfb669b2759b" alt=""
PHOTO: Confiscated items displayed in a slideshow at the recent ESHS PTA meeting, highlighting ongoing security concerns.
A crackdown on contraband at Elmore Stoutt High School (ESHS) has sparked heated confrontations between parents and school officials, with administrators raising concerns about aggressive behavior from guardians and a troubling rise in prohibited items on campus.
In a letter sent to parents on February 20, Principal Vanessa Garraway revealed that routine searches at the school uncovered a significant amount of contraband and illegal substances among students. The alarming findings prompted stricter policies and the involvement of School Resource Officers from the Royal Virgin Islands Police Force (RVIPF). However, instead of cooperation, some parents have responded with hostility.
“We have seen an increase in parents arriving at school and behaving aggressively towards teachers and administrators,” the letter stated. “This type of behavior will not be tolerated.”
The issue of contraband at the school has been growing, and the administration is now taking a tougher stance. Effective February 24, students caught with prohibited items will not only face confiscation but will also be sent home immediately, with an accompanying suspension. Parents will be required to collect their child in such cases.
“We need parents to do more,” Garraway urged in the letter. “It is your responsibility to check your child’s belongings before they leave for school and have open conversations about the importance of following school rules and making positive choices.”
In response to the escalating situation, School Resource Officers have been stationed on campus to curb violent incidents, monitor student behavior, and enforce discipline. Their presence aims to deter misconduct, particularly in light of growing concerns over students making threats, whether serious or in jest. The school has made it clear that any such threats will be reported directly to the RVIPF.
“We are taking a no-nonsense approach,” Garraway wrote, emphasizing the severity of the situation.
The Ministry of Education has also weighed in, calling on parents to take a more active role in supporting efforts to maintain a secure learning environment. “Recent routine inspections continue to uncover prohibited items which pose serious risks to students’ health and well-being,” the Ministry said in a statement.
The Ministry reiterated that matters involving weapons, alcohol, and drugs will be referred to the RVIPF and the Social Development Department for further intervention. Additionally, officials reminded parents that mobile phones are not among the approved devices for use during the school day.
“We are reinforcing a Zero Tolerance Policy for any behavior or possession of items that compromise school safety,” the Ministry stated. “Our goal is to provide a safe and secure learning environment where students can focus on their education without unnecessary disruptions.”
As ESHS moves forward with these new measures, school officials and the Ministry of Education continue to uphold policies aimed at ensuring a structured and secure environment for all students.
ADVERTISEMENT:
Crime/Police
BVI Native Trevor Hughes’ Fiancée Badly Beaten in Deadly Bronx Parking Dispute
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/18463/1846305f9fc7a0388fe941298bda181b13b4c82b" alt=""
Trevor Hughes, a British Virgin Islands native, was fatally shot, and his fiancée was brutally beaten in a violent dispute over a blocked driveway in the Bronx, authorities said.
Hughes, 49, and his fiancée, 47, had just returned home around 2 a.m. on February 8 when they found a car parked in front of their driveway on Fowler Avenue. After Hughes attempted to resolve the issue by calling 311 and notifying police, the situation escalated. According to authorities, 41-year-old Fallon Wise attacked Hughes’ fiancée, leaving her with multiple facial fractures, including a broken nose and shattered teeth.
During the assault, Hughes was allegedly shot in the abdomen by 46-year-old Lavar Davis. He was rushed to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead.
Davis, who has a history of violent crime, including a prior murder conviction in Schenectady, is charged with second-degree murder. Wise faces charges of assault and harassment.
Hughes, a father of four and a well-known DJ known as DJ Dread, was described as a beloved member of his community. His family expressed devastation, calling the attack “senseless violence over something so petty.”
Both Davis and Wise remain in custody as the investigation continues.
Crime/Police
Governor Accepts Resignation of ACP Pam Trevillion from the RVIPF
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c7acf/c7acf8f288e0ac6c5dd59f89f411af4ff4cb4859" alt=""
The Governor of the British Virgin Islands, Daniel Pruce, has formally accepted the resignation of Assistant Commissioner Pam Trevillion from the Royal Virgin Islands Police Force (RVIPF). In an official memorandum dated February 14, Governor Pruce confirmed Trevillion’s resignation, with her last day of service set for March 8.
Governor Pruce expressed his gratitude for Trevillion’s contributions to the security of the Virgin Islands, stating, “I should like to take this opportunity to thank you for the significant contribution you have made to the security of the Virgin Islands during your tenure at the RVIPF. I wish you every success for the future.”
In the letter which was shared on the official HM Governor’s Office Facebook page, Pruce noted that he had copied the memorandum to Acting Commissioner Vanterpool, the Deputy Governor, and members of the National Security Council (NSC) and the Police Service Commission (PoSC), ensuring that the necessary administrative processes would proceed accordingly.
The official reason for Trevillion’s resignation has not been publicly disclosed.
Previously, reports surfaced on February 12 suggesting that Trevillion had tendered her resignation, but Acting Commissioner of Police Jacqueline Vanterpool had stated that she had not been informed of any such resignation. JTV News reached out to the Office of the Governor for confirmation and awaited a response at that time. The RVIPF also responded to media claims that ACP Trevillion had been placed on forced leave, labeling those reports as “erroneous, misleading, and misinformation.”
In a statement issued on February 10, the RVIPF clarified that there had been no physical confrontation between Vanterpool and Trevillion, and denied any allegations of an investigation—particularly one related to assault—being initiated against the assistant commissioner. Vanterpool urged media outlets to verify information before publication, emphasizing that misinformation could have reputational consequences for both individuals and the RVIPF. No further details were provided regarding Trevillion’s employment status at that time.
-
Crime/Police2 weeks ago
Police Arrest Three in BVI Firearms Crackdown; One Charged with Possession
-
Uncategorized2 weeks ago
One Injured as Masked Gunmen Open Fire near Greenland Football Field
-
Uncategorized6 days ago
BVI Man Fatally Shot in Anguilla; Police Investigate Homicide
-
Uncategorized2 weeks ago
Gunman Arrested in Fatal Shooting of BVI Native Over Parking Dispute
-
Crime/Police1 day ago
Tensions Flare as Parents Confront Elmore Stoutt High School Staff Over Contraband Crackdown
-
Uncategorized1 week ago
Intruder Breaks into One Mart East End, Police confirm
-
Crime/Police4 days ago
BVI Native Trevor Hughes’ Fiancée Badly Beaten in Deadly Bronx Parking Dispute
-
Uncategorized2 weeks ago
RVIPF Refutes Allegations of Physical Confrontation Between Acting Commissioner and ACP Trevillion